Case study collection

Illustration: GlobeIllustration: Globe

There are lots of ways to use case studies!

Include them in a presentation, use them to help workshop participants learn about and analyse FORB violations, or use them to challenge stereotypes about perpetrators and victims.

FORB around the world

These brief case studies are designed to enable participants reflect on violations of FORB in different contexts. They are designed for use with the ‘FORB around the world’ exercise but can be used in many other ways. You can find the exercise in the FORB facilitators toolkit and the exercise bank (on the link below).

You can find handouts of the case studies here.

FORB around the world

A group discussion exercise based on case studies, designed to follow a knowledge input on understanding violations of FORB.

Excercise Details for FORB around the world

  • 1 h 5 min
  • Group exercise
  • Case study/scenario
See the exercise

10 cases illustrating a range of FORB issues across the globe

Persecution of Afro-Brazilian traditional religions

In Brazil, followers of traditional Afro-Brazilian religions are facing violent attacks from neo-Pentecostal neighbours and gangs who consider their religion to be demonic and evil.

Religious altar of the traditional Afro-Brazilian Umbanda religionReligious altar of the traditional Afro-Brazilian Umbanda religion

Hindu-nationalism and minorities in India

The Indian government is increasingly promoting and enforcing policies that negatively affect Muslims, Christians, Sikhs, Dalits, and other religious minorities based on an ideological vision of a Hindu state.

Indian couple on beachIndian couple on beach

Minorities and freethinkers in Algeria  

Algerian authorities have sentenced individuals for blasphemy and proselytization, closed dozens of Protestant churches, and charged religious minorities with gathering illegally, despite providing no legal way for them to worship together.

Prayer in an Ahmadiyya mosque.Prayer in an Ahmadiyya mosque.

State control and genocide in China

Underground Catholics, house church Protestants, Tibetan Buddhists and Falun Gong adherents have faced harassment, detention, demolition of places of worship and torture. In Xinjiang province, Uighurs have faced genocide.

Elderly bearded Uighur man in Xinjiang province, ChinaElderly bearded Uighur man in Xinjiang province, China

Targeting of Muslims in the Central African Republic

The Muslim minority has borne the brunt of political and ethnoreligious violence. Attacks on individuals and places of worship, and sexual violence towards women have been widespread.

Muslim women displaced by violence, Central African RepublicMuslim women displaced by violence, Central African Republic

The Baha’i community in Iran  

The government of Iran considers the Baha’i faith to be heretical and has systematically persecuted the Baha’i community since 1979. Adib Vali lost his place in 7th grade when the school discovered he was Baha’i.

Adib Vali, Baha'i student thrown out of top schoolAdib Vali, Baha'i student thrown out of top school

Hate crimes in Sweden

Crimes facing religious groups range from verbal abuse, being pushed, a headscarf being pulled to threats, severe forms of violence, vandalism of religious sites and arson.

Muslim woman, Stockholm, SwedenMuslim woman, Stockholm, Sweden

Religious law in Malaysia

Revathi Massosai was born to converts to Islam but brought up a Hindu by her Hindu grandmother. Revathi was sent to an Islamic re-education centre for six months for marrying a Hindu and refusing to return to Islam.

Revathi Massosai and her child in the court buildingRevathi Massosai and her child in the court building

Minorities in Russia

A wide range of legislation is used to persecute religious minorities in Russia. The 1996 religion law sets strict registration requirements and empowers state officials to impede and monitor religious groups’ activities.

Buddhist monastery, Siberia, RussiaBuddhist monastery, Siberia, Russia

Rohingya Muslims in Myanmar

According to the UNHCR, approximately 720,000 Rohingya refugees have fled targeted violence and human rights violations in Myanmar since August 2017. Nearly 80% of Rohingya refugees are women and children.

Rohingya Muslims fleeing MyanmarRohingya Muslims fleeing Myanmar

FORB and gender equality

The following case studies are designed to enable participants reflect on the multiple vulnerabilities that women and girls face based on their gender and their religious identity. They cover a range of topics from employment discrimination to harmful traditional practices to extreme societal or governmental violence, including sexual violence.

The case studies are designed for use with the ‘FORB and gender equality’ exercise which you can find in the FORB facilitators toolkit and the exercise bank (on the link below). Handouts are available for the case studies, and PowerPoint or video resources are available to illustrate some cases. Find all resources here.

FORB and gender equality

A group discussion exercise based on a selected case study.  

Excercise Details for FORB and gender equality

  • 1 h 45 min
  • Group exercise
  • Case study/scenario
Find the exercise here

7 case studies exploring the relationship between women’s rights and FORB

Vasha and Ayesha’s stories – United Kingdom

Muslim women in Britain are three times more likely to be unemployed that women in general. Women who wear the hijab bear the brunt of discrimination.

Stock photo: Muslim woman eating breakfast with familyStock photo: Muslim woman eating breakfast with family

Sofalta’s story – Nepal

In parts of Nepal, traditional beliefs lead women to be considered bad luck during menstruation. These beliefs are so deeply held that families take extreme risks, isolating menstruating girls and women in cowsheds or menstruation huts in a centuries-old tradition of Chhaupadi.

Young Nepali woman who fears staying in the menstruation hutYoung Nepali woman who fears staying in the menstruation hut

An 8-year-old nomad girl’s story – India

In 2018, an eight-year-old girl was abducted, gang raped and murdered in a plot to strike fear in her Muslim nomadic tribe, the Bakarwal, and drive them from the rugged Himalayan region where they live as shepherds. 

Protesters demonstrate against the rape and murder of an 8 year old girl, Kashmir, IndiaProtesters demonstrate against the rape and murder of an 8 year old girl, Kashmir, India

Maira’s story – Forced conversion and marriage in Pakistan

14 year old Maira Shahbaz was abducted at gunpoint and forced to convert to Islam and marry one of her abductors. She escaped and now lives in hiding.

Photo - Maira ShabaazPhoto - Maira Shabaaz

Qelbinur’s story – Forced sterilisation in China

Up to 1.8 million Uyghurs have been forced into to ‘re-education’ camps. The Chinese government has also enforced systematic sterilisation policies on Uyghur women to reduce the birth rate of the minority.

Qelbinur Sediq in exile in EuropeQelbinur Sediq in exile in Europe

Hajia’s story – Witch hunts in Africa

In at least 36 countries, many of which are in Africa, people are persecuted due to accusations of witchcraft. In 2014, 700 women were killed following accusations of witchcraft in Tanzania alone.  Elderly women make up the majority of those targeted.

Elderly African womanElderly African woman

Andin’s story – Indonesia

Forced exorcism is a common occurrence for transgender women in Indonesia. Throughout the country it is widely believed that being gay or transgender results from being possessed by evil spirits.

Backstreet, IndonesiaBackstreet, Indonesia

The expert advisors –
In depth FORB and gender case studies

Two more in-depth case studies and scenarios exploring issues of FORB and gender, focusing on the abduction and forced marriage of minority girls in Pakistan and religious personal status laws in Egypt. The scenarios are designed for use with ‘The expert advisors’ exercise which you can find in the FORB trainers toolkit and the Exercise bank (on the link below).

Find handouts of the scenarios here.

The expert advisors

In this role-play exercise, the participants have just been promoted to the role of Technical Experts on FORB for all at the UN Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights.

Excercise Details for The expert advisors

  • 1 h 40 min
  • Group exercise
  • Role-play/drama
Find the exercise here

2 in-depth case study scenarios

Abduction, forced conversion and forced marriage in Pakistan

Women and girls from religious minority backgrounds – Christians, Hindus, Hazara and Ahmadi – are disproportionately targeted with specific forms of sexual and gender based violence, such as ideologically motivated sexual grooming. 

Christian girls in school, PakistanChristian girls in school, Pakistan

Religious personal status laws, FORB and discrimination against women in Egypt 

Personal status laws impact well beyond the private sphere, for instance affecting women’s economic empowerment – the ability to open a bank account or own land and property.

Christian women in church, EgyptChristian women in church, Egypt

Speaking of religion

These case studies from Nigeria, Pakistan and Myanmar are designed to enable participants reflect on the intersections between freedom of religion or belief and freedom of expression. They are designed for use with the ‘Speaking of religion’ exercise which you can find in the FORB facilitators toolkit and the exercise bank (on the link below).

You can find handouts of the case studies here.

Speaking of religion

A think-pair-share exercise in which participants reflect on barriers to freely expressing religion or beliefs in their context.

Excercise Details for Speaking of religion

  • 1 h 20 min
  • Multi-format exercise
  • Think-pair-share
Find the exercise here

3 short cases studies on freedom of expression

Mubarak’s story – Nigeria

Mubarak Bala faces a 24-year prison sentence for Facebook posts questioning whether there is life after death.

Mubarak BalaMubarak Bala

Shafqat and Shagufta’s story – Pakistan

After 7 years on death row accused of blasphemy, this couple was acquitted but had to flee the country with their children due to death threats.

Pakistani Christians attend mass. Minorities are particularly vulnerable to blasphemy accusations.Pakistani Christians attend mass. Minorities are particularly vulnerable to blasphemy accusations.

Htin Lin Oo’s story – Myanmar

A prominent writer, Htin Linn Oo was sentenced to two years in prison, for ‘insulting religion’ by criticising members of the Buddhist clergy for misusing Buddhism to incite religious hatred.

Buddhist monks in classroom in Maymio monastery , Myanmar. Some nationalist Buddhist leaders have engaged in incitement to violence against Muslim minorities.Buddhist monks in classroom in Maymio monastery , Myanmar. Some nationalist Buddhist leaders have engaged in incitement to violence against Muslim minorities.

COVID-19 : Legitimate limitations?

The seven case studies below are designed to accompany the exercise ‘Covid 19 – Legitimate limitations’, which you can find in the exercise bank and in the FORB facilitators toolkit.

Handouts of the case studies can be downloaded here.

Covid-19 – legitimate limitations

A group discussion exercise based on case studies, designed to follow a knowledge input on legitimate limitations of FORB.

Excercise Details for Covid-19 – legitimate limitations

  • 2 h 10 min
  • Group exercise
  • Case study/scenario
See the exercise

7 case studies looking at FORB restricitons justified on public health grounds

Algeria: Churches remained closed amidst pandemic 

Covid restrictions kept in place for churches when mosques opened again.

The Catholic Basilica of Notre Dame d'Afrique, AlgiersThe Catholic Basilica of Notre Dame d'Afrique, Algiers

Azerbaijan: Detentions for attending religious commemorations  

A case focusing on proportionality and discrimination in applying punishments for violating public health-based limitations.

Juma mosque, Baku, AzerbaijanJuma mosque, Baku, Azerbaijan

France and Germany: Blanket bans on meeting in places of worship  

This case revolves around whether complete bans on meeting in places of worship were necessary and proportionate.

Church in Germany notifies parishoners of closure due to COVID restrictionsChurch in Germany notifies parishoners of closure due to COVID restrictions

Gabon: Strict regulations and police violence  

This case focuses on the necessity and proportionality of restrictions and the excessive use of force by police.

Saint Marie Catholic Cathedral, Libreville, GabonSaint Marie Catholic Cathedral, Libreville, Gabon

Myanmar: COVID-19 restrictions and punishments  

This case revolves around proportionality and discrimination in the application of punishments.

Authorities in Myanmar lock down a house where a woman has tested positive for COVID-19Authorities in Myanmar lock down a house where a woman has tested positive for COVID-19

Sri Lanka: Compulsory cremations  

This case focuses on states taking unnecessary measures that severely and specifically impact minorities.

Health worker in Kaluthara, Sri Lanka, March 2020Health worker in Kaluthara, Sri Lanka, March 2020

USA: Megachurch pastor ignores public health regulations  

This case explores the responsibilities of religious leaderships.

Stock photo: face mask on church pewStock photo: face mask on church pew